Based on undergraduate offerings and enrollment size, the following schools are considered the University of Maine at Farmington's Peer Institutions in the same 2005 Carnegie Classification.

Carnegie Peer Institutions

• Limestone College (SC)
• Lyndon State College (VT)
• Maranatha Baptist Bible College (WI)
• Marietta College (OH)
• Messiah College (PA)
• Milligan College (TN)
• Missouri Southern State University (MO)
• Missouri Western State University (MO)
• Nevada State College at Henderson (NV)
• Northwestern College (IA)
• Northwestern Oklahoma State Univ (OK)
• Notre Dame College (OH)
• Ohio Christian University (OH)
• Roger Williams University (RI)
• Seton Hill University (PA)
• Southern Adventist University (TN)
• Texas A&M University at Galveston (TX)
• Tri-State University (IN)
• Trinity Christian College (IL)
• Unity College (ME)
• University of Advancing Technology (AZ)
• University of Maine at Fort Kent (ME)
• University of Minnesota-Crookston (MN)
• University of Pittsburgh-Bradford (PA)
• Univ of Science and Arts of Oklahoma (OK)
• University of South Carolina Upstate (SC)
• University of the Virgin Islands (USVI)
• Urbana University (OH)
• U.S. Merchant Marine Academy (NY)
• Valley City State University (ND)
• Virginia Intermont College (VA)
• Wesley College (DE)
• West Liberty State College (WV)
• Western Governors University (UT)
• Wilmington College (OH)
• Wilson College (PA)
• Winston-Salem State University (NC)
• York College - CUNY (NY)
• York College of Pennsylvania (PA)

• Adrian College (MI)
• Alice Lloyd College (KY)
• Barton College (NC)
• Belmont Abbey College (NC)
• Bethany College (KS)
• Blackburn College (IL)
• Brescia University KY)
• Buena Vista University (IA)
• Campbellsville University (KY)
• Catawba College (NC)
• Central Methodist University (MO)
• Chadron State College (NE)
• Champlain College (VT)
• Clayton State University (GA)
• Colby-Sawyer College (NH)
• College of Saint Mary (NE)
• College of the Ozarks (MO)
• Concord University (WV)
• Concordia University at Austin (TX)
• Covenant College (GA)
• Defiance College (OH)
• Delaware Valley College (PA)
• Dickinson State University (ND)
• Dordt College (IA)
• Eureka College (IL)
• Faulkner University (AL)
• Flagler College (FL)
• Franklin College (IN)
• Grace College and Theological Seminary (IN)
• Grand View College (IA)
• Harris-Stowe State University (MO)
• High Point University (NC)
• Indiana University-East (IN)
• John Brown University (AR)
• Judson College (IL)
• Kentucky State University (KY)
• LaGrange College (GA)
• Lander University (SC)
• Lebanon Valley College (PA)